Dr. Asiya Staff asked 1 week ago
1) The couple has been married for several years and met frequently in public and in a car. They met twice in a private room with the husband's intention to establish a marital relationship; however, while other physical intimacy occurred, actual intercourse did not take place because the wife was menstruating at the time. Now, a separation is occurring via divorce or Khula because the husband is refusing to perform the Rukhsati (formal send-off). In this scenario, is the wife required to observe the Iddah? If so, when does it begin?
2) If someone undergoes therapy post-divorce, is it permissible to disclose details about the marriage, the nature of the relationship, the spouse's behavior, and specific incidents to a therapist? The intention behind this is to identify one's own toxic patterns and to facilitate healing. Is this correct, or should one maintain the same level of marital privacy with a therapist as they would with others and refrain from speaking openly?
Dr. Asiya Staff answered 1 week ago
1: Regarding Iddah and Separation
The situation is that the Nikkah took place many years ago, and the couple met frequently, including in private. Although the husband expressed the desire for marital relations, intercourse never took place because the wife was menstruating during those instances. Now, separation is occurring—likely through Khula—because the husband is refusing to perform the Rukhsati.
Will the Iddah (waiting period) be mandatory for the girl? The fact is, even if intercourse did not occur, they were in seclusion (Khalwat), and feelings naturally develop in such settings. Jurists term this Khalwat-e-Sahiha (Valid Seclusion). The reasoning is that if the possibility of intimacy was established—even if the girl or the man declined for any reason—it is legally treated as if the marriage was consummated. Therefore, since the husband is not proceeding with the Rukhsati and the girl is seeking Khula, the man is obligated to pay the full Mahr (dowry), and it is mandatory for the woman to complete the Iddah. There is no harm in completing the three-month cycle; please ensure it is observed.
2: Regarding Post-Divorce Therapy
Regarding the second point, you need to take post-divorce therapy, which will obviously involve opening up about many painful experiences. In this context, the rule of "marital privacy" does not apply in the way you might think. You should share these details with your therapist. Backbiting (Gheebat) is a different matter; here, we are discussing the relationship and sexual matters between a husband and wife for the sake of healing.
It is natural for someone who has endured such a painful situation to feel anger and hurt. As long as you are speaking the truth and not trying to belittle him or portray yourself as superior, there is no involvement of backbiting or slander in your case. May Allah make things easy for you and protect us all from such sins.
Please login or Register to submit your answer
